Penn Humanities Forum on Belief

Freemasonry: Paradox Amid the Mysteries

Margaret Jacob

Wednesday, February 18, 2004


Freemasonry has long been associated with secrecy and intrigue, according to 18th-century historian Margaret Jacob. Don Brown's popular bestseller, The Da Vinci Code (Doubleday, 2003), exploits this perception, locating a fictitious archival call number of a secret dossier on masonic lodges at the heart of the story's suspense. While Brown's book may not shed the light of truth and historical accuracy on the subject of the Masons, Jacob does acknowledge that mystery has been an integral part of masonic lodge culture since its inception.

From medieval times, guilds and stonemasons used passwords and codes to exclude itinerants and non-guild members. Guild rituals further protected the inner circle of members in their progression from apprentice to master mason. Against the liturgical backdrop of the times in which much knowledge was itself still mysterious, these guild members were a "cut above," literate and steeped in the rudiments of Euclidean geometry, essentially fulfilling the role of architects.

By the mid-18th century, guilds were initiating members who had never cut stone. This constituted a crucial shift from "operative" guild stonemasons to a "speculative" society of educated members. Freemasonry became a force of religious tolerance and social mobility, in which men and, in some cases, women were honored on the basis of merit rather than birth. These increasingly genteel societies constituted a new movement away from traditional, sectarian life. Lodges fostered a literate culture with particular interest in military skills and engineering. Freemasons even developed their own mythology of intellectual filiation with the figure of Hermes Trismegistus as the ancient Egyptian source of their learned knowledge.

Masonic societies were, on the one hand, secretive, ritualistic, and devoted to internal hierarchy. On the other hand, they upheld the ideals of merit, equality, and enlightenment, believing that all brothers should be philosophers. A masonic manuscript of 1659 draws an organic link between masonic wisdom and natural governance. This concept, along with the increasing popularity of the notion of the body as the sum of constituent parts, ushered the concept of a "constitution" as we know it into legal and political parlance. The 1723 publication of the Book of Constitutions, an amalgam of the constitutions used by individual lodges, bears early witness to the centrality of their importance within masonic culture.

 

In the 18th century, masonic lodges became venues for the articulation of liberal political ideals, including the opposition to French absolutism and the affirmation of religious tolerance, from theism and pantheism to atheism. Some French lodges also extended membership to women. Freemasonry, condemned as a "new form of religion" by the Church, denoted enthusiasm for new Enlightenment ideas and attracted progressive, secular thinkers.

By the late 18th century, lodges began to form bona fide political ties. Masonic lodges served as the sites for revolutionary discussion of self-governance in British colonies, just as they did in pre-revolutionary France. On the opposite side of the political spectrum, Sweden's court in its entirety joined lodges; Parisian lodges boasted ambassadorial connections; in Berlin and Vienna, lodges enjoyed royal support and membership. Caught between the concepts of modern contract and feudal birthright, late 18th-century society found leadership in freemasonry in its movement toward disciplined decorum, interiority, public discussion, sociability, and uncensored private reading. In some cases, lodge memberships constituted national representative constituencies; nation and lodge grew so intertwined as to become difficult to parse.

Masonic culture made the abstract ideals of reason, equality, and self-governance concrete, if still difficult to attain. This liberalism was not without its contradictions, as is evidenced in the exclusion of peasants, workers, slaves, and, in most places, women, from lodge membership. In spite of this, Jacob contends that freemasonry looked more to the future of human rights and egalitarian ideals than to its medieval past.

From the time of Nazi Germany, the myth of a Jewish masonic conspiracy has persisted. The March 9, 2004, suicide bombing of a masonic temple in Istanbul attributed to Islamic militant groups may indicate that this myth is alive and well, notes Jacob. Both examples demonstrate the extent to which freemasonry, for its liberalism, would be hated by enemies of democracy.

• — •

 
 
maincalendarfellowshipscoursessitemap
annual topicsabout the forumcontact us
PHF homepage